Use the same questions across your shortlist and compare the written answers.
Set the commercial context
Begin with your budget, objective, sales process and constraints. Ask what the agency would need to inspect before recommending a plan. A productive interview should reveal how the team thinks and where it needs more evidence.
Test the working relationship
Ask about the account lead, regular meetings and escalation. Discuss the internal resources you can provide. Invite the team to describe a situation where it advised against increasing ad spend and what evidence led to that decision.
Inspect the reporting approach
Request an anonymized report or a walkthrough of the proposed reporting structure. Ask how platform metrics connect to business outcomes. Make sure you understand which data sources would be available and what the report cannot establish.
Leave with explicit next steps
Summarize scope, ownership, fees, notice periods and open questions in writing. Compare the same topics across agencies. Follow references where available and use the final contract to resolve differences between the sales conversation and the proposed delivery.
Take these questions to your shortlist
- Who needs to be on the second call?
- Which data will support the plan?
- What remains unresolved before a contract?
