Look past the overall rating to the projects behind the feedback.
Open the review record
Read the actual profile instead of relying on a star graphic on the agency website. Look for review dates, project descriptions, budgets and the services discussed. A review of a website redesign may say little about paid-search management. Identify the feedback that reflects the work you want to commission.
Separate listings from awards
Being listed on Clutch, appearing in a category ranking and receiving a dated award are distinct claims. Check the wording and source of each. If an agency cites a geographic list, preserve that context. A directory position can change as its own filters and commercial programs change.
Read a range of experiences
Consider the number of reviews, the time period they cover and whether several describe similar strengths. Read critical feedback and any response with the same attention. A smaller set of detailed reviews can still be informative, but uncertainty grows when the record is thin or old.
Take the next question to the agency
Use review details to ask about communication, reporting and staffing. Request a reference from a comparable account where practical. Record the date you reviewed the profile. Avoid treating the profile score as a forecast of your future return on ad spend.
Take these questions to your shortlist
- Do the reviewed services include PPC?
- How recent and detailed is the feedback?
- Does the cited award match the source wording?
